UserName:
PassWord:
Home >> Working Paper
On Middle-class Nature of Classical Economics——Further Discussion of Marx's Civil Theory
Read        DownLoad
TitleOn Middle-class Nature of Classical Economics——Further Discussion of Marx's Civil Theory  
AuthorShen Yue  
OrganizationSchool of Economics and Business Administration, Beijing Normal University 
Emailshenyue@bnu.edu.cn 
Key WordsCitizen; Bourgeoisie; Civil Society; Classical Economics; Western Economics; Western Mainstream Ideology 
AbstractThe terminology “Bürger” in the original German works of Marx and Engels only contains one meaning, but is widely mistranslated as bourgeoisie in Chinese translation. As the earliest scholar who defines the concept of bourgeoisie scientifically, when introducing bourgeoisie (middle class) to Germans, Marx excludes its original meaning of “civil”, while uses “Bourgeoisie” to refer to bourgeois specifically and distinguishes civil from bourgeoisie strictly in German. When writing in French and English, to comply with the language habits of other countries, they still adopt “bourgeoisie” in broader sense, using it to refer to propertied burgher, including bourgeoisie. Translation should be subject to German, the two terms “Bürger” and “Bourgeoisie” should be translated as burgher and bourgeoisie respectively so as to determine whether “bourgeoisie” in French and English is burgher or bourgeoisie. However, the Chinese translator’s practice is on the contrary. They understand “bourgeoisie” in French and English only with one sense ------ bourgeoisie, and in accordance with its corresponding relationship with Bürger, mistake that the latter one also has the meaning of bourgeoisie. This is just the origin of people’s mistaking burgher (or bourgeois) economics for bourgeoisie. 
Serial NumberWP411 
Time2013-02-21 
  • Institute of Economics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences
  • Copyright Economic Research Journal
  • The uploaded articles by this website express the authors¡¯ views, not necessarily the views of this website.
  • Perennial Legal Counsel: Lu Kang (Chong Guang Law Office)
  • ISSN 0577-9154 CN 11-1081/F Postal Distribution Code 2-25l (Domestic) M16 (Overseas)
  • ICP 10211437 (Beijng)
  • No.2,Yuetan Bei Xiaojie, Xicheng District, Beijing 100836, P. R. China
  • Phone/Fax: (+8610) 68034153